.png)
Effective strategic planning requires more than looking inward in today's fast-paced world. Yet, many organizations fall into the trap of “navel gazing”—an approach where strategic discussions focus solely on internal factors without considering the broader industry landscape, competitive forces or emerging market trends. This inward focus often blindsides organizations, leaving them unprepared for change and unresponsive to opportunities.
In this article, we’ll explore why avoiding navel gazing in strategic planning is essential and why engaging a third-party facilitator can make all the difference. By bringing an outside perspective, organizations can better align their strengths with market opportunities, making strategic plans more resilient, adaptive and forward-looking.
The Pitfalls of Navel Gazing in Strategic Planning
“Navel gazing” in strategic planning occurs when organizations concentrate primarily on internal strengths, weaknesses and processes, and fail to understand the external environment. This often happens when a group of internal leaders or board members decide to execute planning efforts without the assistance of a third party. While introspection is valuable, an inward-only focus risks creating plans that are out of sync with market needs, blind to competitive threats and unprepared for emerging challenges.
Examples of Navel Gazing Pitfalls:
Missed Market Shifts: Companies focusing only on current products and processes may fail to recognize changing customer demands or emerging technologies.
Underestimating Competitors: Ignoring external factors can make anticipating competitor moves, new entrants or substitutes challenging.
Overlooking Industry Trends: Organizations that only look inward may overlook important trends, such as shifts in supply chain dynamics or regulatory changes.
A balanced approach that combines internal insights with external perspectives is essential to avoid these risks. Enter tools like SWOT analysis and Porter’s Five Forces, both of which demand an honest look at both internal and external factors.
Why the Right People—and the Right Perspectives—Matter
Creating an effective strategic plan requires diverse perspectives from across the organization. Marketing, customer relations, finance and operations leaders from various departments bring unique insights about the organization’s strengths, weaknesses and external opportunities. But it’s crucial that these voices also look beyond departmental goals to identify opportunities and threats in the broader industry context.
Key Benefits of a Cross-Functional Strategic Planning Team:
Diverse Insights: Each department has different views on organizational strengths, weaknesses and external challenges, making the planning process more comprehensive.
Alignment Across Teams: Cross-functional participation aligns the organization’s strategy with both internal capabilities and market needs.
Balanced Planning: A well-rounded team can help balance short-term departmental goals and long-term strategic aims.
Organizational Understanding: Including key leaders from each department helps create team buy-in to the strategic plan. This also helps your team understand the needs of other departments and how everything fits together.
However, having the right people at the table isn’t always enough to avoid navel gazing. When everyone comes from within the organization, there’s a risk of groupthink or confirmation bias, where the team unconsciously looks for data that supports their existing views. This is where an external facilitator can add tremendous value.
Why a Third-Party Facilitator Makes a Difference
A third-party facilitator—a consultant, strategic advisor or industry expert—brings an outside perspective to the planning process, helping the organization think more critically about its internal assumptions and external opportunities. By guiding discussions, an experienced facilitator can encourage a more profound analysis, ask tough questions and prevent the conversation from getting bogged down in internal-only thinking.
Roles of a Third-Party Facilitator:
Providing Objectivity: An external facilitator offers unbiased insights, challenges assumptions and pushes the team to think critically about both internal and external factors.
Bringing Industry Knowledge: Many facilitators have insights from across industries, helping organizations identify trends, strategies or potential risks they might not have considered.
Ensuring Structure and Focus: Skilled facilitators guide the team through structured frameworks like SWOT and Five Forces, ensuring the planning process stays comprehensive and goal oriented.
Encouraging Honest Dialogue: A facilitator helps teams address tough questions and confront challenges head-on, without the usual internal politics or hierarchy concerns.
How a Third-Party Facilitator Adds Value Through Strategic Frameworks
SWOT analysis and Porter’s Five Forces are widely used strategic planning tools that require a critical eye to be effective. While SWOT examines internal (strengths and weaknesses) and external (opportunities and threats) factors, Porter’s Five Forces specifically analyzes competitive pressures in the industry, including the threat of new entrants, the bargaining power of buyers and suppliers, the threat of substitutes and industry rivalry. For a deeper dive into these frameworks, check out this blog article.
A third-party facilitator can ensure these frameworks are used effectively by prompting the team to look outward rather than just focusing on internal perceptions. For instance, when conducting a SWOT analysis, a facilitator might push the team to specify exactly which external trends pose threats—or challenge the team to consider whether they’re truly capitalizing on their strengths. During a Five Forces analysis, a facilitator might prompt questions such as:
Who are our biggest competitors, and what differentiates them from us?
How could emerging technologies or substitute products impact us?
How vulnerable are we to supply chain shifts or changes in buyer power?
Common Mistakes When Conducting Strategic Planning Internally
Overlooking External Factors: Teams often miss important external threats and opportunities without an outsider's perspective, reducing their strategy’s effectiveness.
Assumptions Go Unchallenged: Internal-only teams may hold onto outdated or untested assumptions about their strengths, competitive position or market needs.
Lack of Accountability: Strategic plans can become overly ambitious or impractical when teams don’t have someone to ask critical questions or hold them accountable for realistic, actionable goals.
Moving Beyond Navel Gazing for a Resilient Strategic Plan
Strategic planning requires an honest assessment of internal resources and an objective assessment of external challenges. A third-party facilitator offers an invaluable outside perspective, guiding teams to confront assumptions, uncover blind spots, and balance internal strengths and market opportunities. By saying “no” to navel gazing and embracing an outward-looking approach, organizations can create strategic plans aligned with their goals and be resilient in the face of change.
So, next time you’re planning your strategy, consider bringing in an experienced facilitator. Their perspective could be the key to unlocking a more comprehensive, actionable, and forward-thinking plan—one that is as attuned to market realities as it is to organizational goals. If your organization is developing a strategic plan, consider contacting our team of professionals to discuss facilitation options. With over 30 years of industry experience, a preliminary consultation with our team is always worth the time!